Motorcycle Crash With a Deer in PA: Who Pays and Do You Have a Claim?
Written and legally reviewed by Sean P. Quinlan, Esq., PA Attorney ID 86858 — Last updated
Hit a deer or swerved to avoid one on your motorcycle in Pennsylvania? How 75 Pa.C.S. 1711 and 1714, your own policy, health insurance, phantom vehicle UM claims and government immunity rules decide who pays.
If you crashed your motorcycle after hitting or swerving to avoid a deer in Pennsylvania, there is usually no one at fault to sue for the deer itself, and a motorcycle carries no required medical benefits: 75 Pa.C.S. § 1711(a) excludes motorcycles, and § 1714 says a motorcycle operator or occupant "cannot recover first party benefits." Payment then comes from the coverage you bought on your own policy, your health insurance, and any claim against someone whose negligence played a part. If an unidentified vehicle forced the swerve, uninsured motorist coverage may apply under § 1702, but § 1702 conditions that on a police report and on notice to your insurer within 30 days or as soon as practicable thereafter. Passengers may have a claim against a negligent operator.
A rider who brakes hard or swerves for a deer can go down without ever touching the animal. In this article I explain who pays in that situation under Pennsylvania law, when a deer crash turns out to involve a real liability or insurance claim, and what to do in the first days. It is part of the firm's Pennsylvania motorcycle accident resources, and it focuses on a question the general guides skip: what happens when the "other party" was a wild animal.
The Short Version: Three Questions Decide Who Pays
Almost every deer-related motorcycle crash sorts into one of three situations. Which one you are in decides where the money can come from.
| What happened | Likely sources of payment | Key Pennsylvania rule |
|---|---|---|
| You hit a deer, or went down avoiding one, and no other vehicle was involved | Your own motorcycle policy's optional coverages (if purchased); your health insurance | No required medical benefit on a motorcycle: 75 Pa.C.S. §§ 1711(a), 1714 |
| An unidentified car or truck forced you to brake or swerve (for example, it swerved into your lane avoiding the deer) and drove off | Uninsured motorist (UM) coverage, if you have it, plus the sources above | "Unidentified motor vehicle" definition and notice conditions: 75 Pa.C.S. § 1702 |
| An identified driver contributed (tailgating you, swerving into you, following too closely after you braked) | That driver's liability insurance; possibly underinsured motorist coverage | Negligence and comparative fault: 42 Pa.C.S. § 7102(a) |
| You were a passenger | A claim against the operator's liability coverage if the operator was negligent; health insurance | Passengers are also barred from first party benefits: § 1714 |
Road defects and government claims are discussed below, along with the reason a claim "for the deer" against the Commonwealth generally fails.
Why Your Motorcycle Policy Does Not Work Like Car Insurance
Most Pennsylvanians know that a car policy pays some medical bills regardless of fault. That rule comes from 75 Pa.C.S. § 1711(a), which requires insurers to include "a medical benefit in the amount of $5,000." But the same subsection carves out "recreational vehicles not intended for highway use, motorcycles, motor-driven cycles or motorized pedalcycles or like type vehicles." A motorcycle policy is not required to carry that benefit.
Section 1714 then goes further. It provides that "an operator or occupant of a recreational vehicle not intended for highway use, motorcycle, motor-driven cycle, motorized pedalcycle or like type vehicle required to be registered under this title cannot recover first party benefits." Under § 1702, "first party benefits" means "medical benefits, income loss benefits, accidental death benefits and funeral benefits." Read together, the text means a rider or passenger on a motorcycle generally cannot recover those statutory first party benefits, and that includes trying to use the medical benefit on a car policy in the same household. The rider's own motorcycle policy is a separate question. My earlier article on whether motorcycles carry medical benefits in Pennsylvania covers this in more detail.
What your own motorcycle policy may cover
Motorcycle policies sold in Pennsylvania often include optional coverages beyond the liability coverage the law requires. Depending on what you bought, your declarations page may show some of these:
- Medical payments coverage. Some insurers offer it as an option on motorcycle policies. Because it is a policy term rather than a statutory first party benefit, what it pays, how much, and in what order are set by the policy language.
- Collision and comprehensive. These pay for damage to the bike itself. Policies differ on whether contact with an animal is handled under comprehensive or collision, and on how a crash with no contact (you went down avoiding the deer) is treated. Read the definitions.
- Uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage. Under 75 Pa.C.S. § 1731(a), these coverages must be offered on motor vehicle liability policies for vehicles "registered or principally garaged in this Commonwealth," but "Purchase of uninsured motorist and underinsured motorist coverages is optional." The Vehicle Code (§ 102) defines a motorcycle as "a motor vehicle having a seat or saddle for the use of the rider," so check whether your motorcycle policy shows UM and UIM limits.
Get the full policy, not just the ID card. If an adjuster says something is "not covered," ask for the policy language in writing.
Health insurance
For a rider with no medical payments coverage, health insurance is usually what pays the hospital and the surgeon in the first months. Expect deductibles and co-pays. If you later recover money from someone else, your health plan may claim reimbursement. Pennsylvania's anti-subrogation provision, 75 Pa.C.S. § 1720, says that "In actions arising out of the maintenance or use of a motor vehicle, there shall be no right of subrogation or reimbursement from a claimant's tort recovery" for certain listed benefits, including benefits paid under a program or group contract under § 1719. Whether that protection reaches a particular health plan in a motorcycle case depends on the type of plan and the facts, and an attorney can confirm how this applies to your case.
When a Deer Crash Is Really a Claim Against Someone
There is usually no one to sue because a wild deer ran into the road. But many deer crashes on a motorcycle involve other people, and riders often leave those details out of the first police interview.
Another driver made the deer encounter worse
Common examples: a driver behind you was following too closely and struck you or your bike after you braked for the deer; an oncoming driver swerved across the center line to avoid the deer and forced you off the road; a driver who had just hit the deer left it, or debris, in your lane. In those cases the other driver's conduct is judged under ordinary negligence law. Pennsylvania's safe-speed statute, 75 Pa.C.S. § 3361, provides that no person shall drive "at a speed greater than will permit the driver to bring his vehicle to a stop within the assured clear distance ahead." The Pennsylvania Supreme Court described that rule in Lockhart v. List, 665 A.2d 1176 (Pa. 1995): it "simply requires a driver to control the speed of his or her vehicle so that he or she will be able to stop within the distance of whatever may reasonably be expected to be within the driver's path."
The "sudden emergency" argument you should expect
Insurers defending deer crashes often raise the sudden emergency doctrine. In Lockhart, the Court explained that the doctrine "is available as a defense to a party who suddenly and unexpectedly finds him or herself confronted with a perilous situation which permits little or no opportunity to apprehend the situation and act accordingly." The same opinion added an important limit: "a person cannot avail himself of the protection of this doctrine if that person was himself driving carelessly or recklessly." So the dispute is usually over facts. Was the other driver speeding at dusk in a posted deer area? Following too closely? Distracted? Those questions are answered with evidence, which is why the scene photos, the bike, and any vehicle or dash-camera video matter.
Comparative fault
The insurer may also argue that you share the blame. Under 42 Pa.C.S. § 7102(a), your own negligence does not bar recovery "where such negligence was not greater than the causal negligence of the defendant or defendants against whom recovery is sought," but your damages are "diminished in proportion to the amount of negligence attributed to the plaintiff." The comparative negligence FAQ walks through how that works in practice.
The Phantom Vehicle: When an Unidentified Driver Forced the Swerve
A common version: a car ahead swerves for a deer, cuts across your lane, and keeps going. You go down without touching the car or the animal, and the driver is gone.
Pennsylvania's definition of an "uninsured motor vehicle" in 75 Pa.C.S. § 1702 includes "An unidentified motor vehicle that causes an accident resulting in injury provided the accident is reported to the police or proper governmental authority and the claimant notifies his insurer within 30 days, or as soon as practicable thereafter, that the claimant or his legal representative has a legal action arising out of the accident." Under § 1731(b), UM coverage protects "persons who suffer injury arising out of the maintenance or use of a motor vehicle and are legally entitled to recover damages therefor from owners or operators of uninsured motor vehicles."
The statutory text speaks of a vehicle that "causes an accident"; it does not, on its face, mention physical contact. Your policy may contain its own conditions, such as proof requirements, so read it and ask an attorney how this applies to your case.
The reporting conditions are where these claims are won or lost. In Vanderhoff v. Harleysville Insurance Co., 78 A.3d 1060 (Pa. 2013), the claimant alleged months after the crash that a phantom vehicle had pulled out and caused the vehicle in front of him to stop suddenly. The police report "contained no mention of a phantom vehicle." The Supreme Court held that late-notice cases are decided by balancing "the extent and success of the insurer's investigation with the insured's reasons for the delay," and that showing prejudice "does not require proof of what the insurer would have found had timely notice been provided." The Court affirmed the Superior Court. The lesson for a rider is direct: tell the responding officer about the other vehicle at the scene, make sure it appears in the report, and give your insurer written notice right away.
If more than one policy could apply, § 1733(a) sets the order: first "A policy covering a motor vehicle occupied by the injured person at the time of the accident," then "A policy covering a motor vehicle not involved in the accident with respect to which the injured person is an insured." For a rider, that often means the motorcycle policy first, subject to each policy's exclusions. My comparison of uninsured versus underinsured motorist claims in Pennsylvania covers stacking, rejection forms and deadlines in more depth.
If You Were the Passenger
A passenger on a motorcycle is an "occupant" under § 1714 and, like the operator, "cannot recover first party benefits." The passenger's path to compensation is usually a liability claim against the operator, if the operator was negligent, plus any claim against another driver. When the operator is a spouse or friend, the claim is generally made against the operator's liability insurance, subject to that policy's terms and exclusions. A deer appearing suddenly does not automatically make the operator negligent; the questions are the same ones above about speed, following distance, lighting and attention. My article on whose insurance pays when a motorcycle passenger is hurt goes through the priority questions.
Can You Sue PennDOT or a Township Over the Deer?
Riders often ask whether the Commonwealth is responsible for deer on a state highway, especially on a stretch with known deer crossings. The statutes and the case law point the same way. Pennsylvania's sovereign immunity waiver for animals, 42 Pa.C.S. § 8522(b)(6), states: "Damages shall not be recoverable under this paragraph on account of any injury caused by wild animals, including but not limited to bears and deer, except as otherwise provided by statute." The local-agency counterpart, 42 Pa.C.S. § 8542(b)(8), uses the same words.
A rider may try the highway exception instead. Section 8522(b)(4) waives immunity for a dangerous condition of "highways under the jurisdiction of a Commonwealth agency," and § 8522(b)(5) covers potholes "or other similar conditions created by natural elements," where the claimant must show the agency "had actual written notice of the dangerous condition of the highway a sufficient time prior to the event." The Commonwealth Court has refused to treat an animal that wandered onto the road as a condition "of" the highway: in Mason & Dixon Lines, Inc. v. Mognet, 645 A.2d 1370 (Pa. Cmwlth. 1994), a case about a cow on the Turnpike, it held that "the cow cannot be said to be an artificial condition or defect 'of' the highway."
That does not end every government claim. If a real road defect, such as a broken pavement edge, a pothole, or a dangerous drop-off, turned a controlled stop into a crash, the analysis changes; my article on road defects and PennDOT or municipal liability explains the exceptions and their notice rules. Any claim against a government unit also carries a short notice deadline: 42 Pa.C.S. § 5522(a)(1) requires a written statement "Within six months from the date that any injury was sustained or any cause of action accrued," filed with the government unit and, for a Commonwealth agency, also with the Attorney General. Damages caps also apply under §§ 8528 and 8553.
Reporting the Crash and the Deer
Two different reporting rules apply, and riders sometimes confuse them.
- Police. Under 75 Pa.C.S. § 3746(a), the driver "shall immediately by the quickest means of communication give notice to the nearest office of a duly authorized police department" if the accident involves "injury to or death of any person" or damage that leaves a vehicle unable to be driven and "therefore requires towing." If the driver is physically unable, an occupant who can must give the notice (§ 3746(b)). For a phantom-vehicle claim, a police report is also one of the § 1702 conditions.
- The Game Commission. In its motorist guidance, the Pennsylvania Game Commission has said a driver who hits a deer "is not required to report the accident to the Game Commission." If you or another person want to keep a deer killed by a vehicle, Game Commission regulations allow a person to "take immediate possession of the carcass of a deer or turkey evidently killed accidentally by a motor vehicle," but that person must "contact the Commission to obtain a permit number within 24 hours after having taken possession" (58 Pa. Code § 147.142(a)(2)). The Commission has also said only Pennsylvania residents may claim the carcass.
- A dead deer blocking a state road. PennDOT says that if "a dead deer presents an obvious safety hazard on state roadways," motorists "can call 1-800-FIX-ROAD to have the deer removed."
Once your report exists, a Pennsylvania State Police crash report can be requested online; PSP says "The fee for a crash report is $22" and "Crash reports are available 15 days after the date of the crash."
Fall Riding and Deer: What PennDOT Says
PennDOT's fall driving guidance explains why late-season riding carries this risk: "Fall marks the deer's breeding season," and "deer pay less attention and become bolder as they move around more and travel greater distances seeking mates." It adds that "Primarily nocturnal feeders, deer are most active between sunset and sunrise," and warns that "Since deer often travel in small herds, one deer will usually be followed by others." Its advice is to "Slow down, increase following distance between vehicles, and use caution, particularly where deer crossing signs are posted." My article on Perry County motorcycle crashes on PA 274, PA 850 and PA 34 discusses deer and loose stone on those roads.
What Compensation May Be Available
What you can recover depends on which claim exists.
- Under your own first-party coverages (medical payments, collision or comprehensive, if purchased): what the policy language promises, up to its limits.
- Against a negligent driver, or through UM/UIM coverage: medical expenses, lost wages and lost earning capacity, and, depending on tort status, pain and suffering, scarring and loss of life's pleasures. The compensation FAQ lists the categories.
- Limited tort questions. Section 1705(d)(3) says a person "otherwise bound by the limited tort election shall retain full tort rights if injured while an occupant of a motor vehicle other than a private passenger motor vehicle," and § 1702 defines a private passenger motor vehicle as "A four-wheel motor vehicle." How that applies to a rider is covered in does limited tort apply to motorcycle accidents. Separately, § 1731(d)(2) bars noneconomic damages under UM or UIM for "A person precluded from maintaining an action for noneconomic damages under section 1705." An attorney can confirm how this applies to your case.
- In a fatal crash, the family may have wrongful death and survival claims under 42 Pa.C.S. §§ 8301 and 8302; see wrongful death versus survival actions.
A rider thrown from a motorcycle can suffer head and spine injuries. If you are dealing with one of those, see the page on traumatic brain injury claims.
Mistakes to Avoid After a Deer-Related Motorcycle Crash
- Telling the officer "I hit a deer" and nothing else. If a car forced the swerve, a tailgater hit you, or a driver crossed the center line, say so at the scene. Vanderhoff shows what happens when the phantom vehicle first appears months later.
- Waiting to notify your insurer. Section 1702 asks for notice "within 30 days, or as soon as practicable thereafter." Give it in writing and keep a copy.
- Assuming a car policy's medical benefit will pay. Section 1714 generally bars it for motorcycle operators and occupants. Find your health insurance card and your motorcycle declarations page.
- Repairing or scrapping the bike too soon. Damage patterns can show whether there was contact with an animal, a vehicle, or neither. Photograph everything first. The motorcycle accident FAQ answers related questions.
- Giving a recorded statement before reading your policy. Your own policy may impose cooperation duties, so ask what it requires before you speak, and think carefully before giving any statement to another driver's insurer.
- Ignoring the government notice clock. If a road defect may be involved, the six-month notice under § 5522 can expire long before the two-year lawsuit deadline.
Why Act Now: The Deadlines
Several clocks start on the day of the crash. An injury lawsuit against a negligent driver "must be commenced within two years" under 42 Pa.C.S. § 5524(2). A phantom-vehicle UM claim depends on police and insurer notice that should happen in days, not months. Notice to a government unit is due within six months under § 5522. Evidence is also short-lived: the deer carcass is removed, skid marks fade, and private video is overwritten. The Pennsylvania statute of limitations FAQ explains how these deadlines interact.
What Happens Next
- Medical care comes first, and every symptom should be documented, including head and neck complaints that seem minor.
- The police report is obtained, and the account of any other vehicle is checked for accuracy.
- Every policy that may apply is collected: the motorcycle policy, household auto policies, and health coverage.
- Written notice goes to your insurer, including any UM claim based on an unidentified vehicle.
- The scene, the bike, gear and any video are preserved before repairs or disposal.
- Liability is evaluated: whether another driver, an operator, or a road condition contributed, and whether any government notice is required.
- Claims are presented to the right insurers and, if they do not resolve, move to arbitration under the policy or to a lawsuit before the deadline. See how motorcycle and car accident claims differ.
Why Talk With Sean Quinlan
I am Sean Quinlan, a Pennsylvania attorney since 2001, with offices in Camp Hill and Harrisburg. A deer-related motorcycle crash is often treated as a "no claim" situation by the people involved, when the real answer depends on the policy wording, what other vehicles did, and whether the reporting steps were taken in time. The consultation is free and confidential. It covers which insurance policies may apply, whether another driver or a road condition may share responsibility, whether a phantom-vehicle UM claim is available, and which deadlines are running in your situation.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does my motorcycle insurance pay my medical bills after I hit a deer in Pennsylvania?
Only if you bought coverage that does. Under 75 Pa.C.S. § 1711(a), motorcycles are excluded from the required $5,000 medical benefit, and § 1714 says motorcycle operators and occupants cannot recover first party benefits. Some motorcycle policies include optional medical payments coverage, so check your declarations page. Otherwise health insurance is usually the first payer.
Can I file a claim if I crashed swerving to avoid a deer and never hit it?
There is usually no claim against anyone for the deer itself. But if another vehicle caused or contributed to the crash, you may have a claim against that driver, or an uninsured motorist claim if the driver left and was never identified. Section 1702 requires that the crash be reported to the police and that you notify your insurer within 30 days, or as soon as practicable thereafter.
Is PennDOT responsible for deer on Pennsylvania highways?
Generally no. 42 Pa.C.S. § 8522(b)(6) states that damages are not recoverable under that paragraph "on account of any injury caused by wild animals, including but not limited to bears and deer," and § 8542(b)(8) says the same for local agencies. A separate claim may exist if a genuine road defect contributed, subject to six-month notice under § 5522.
Do I have to report hitting a deer to the Game Commission?
The Game Commission has said a driver is not required to report the accident to it. You must notify police when the crash causes injury or leaves a vehicle needing a tow (75 Pa.C.S. § 3746). Anyone who keeps a road-killed deer must contact the Commission for a permit number within 24 hours of taking possession (58 Pa. Code § 147.142(a)(2)).
I was a passenger on the motorcycle. Who pays for my injuries?
Passengers on a motorcycle also cannot recover first party benefits under § 1714. If the operator was negligent, for example by riding too fast for conditions at dusk, you may have a claim against the operator's liability insurance. Health insurance and any claim against another driver may also apply.
Talk to a Pennsylvania Injury Lawyer About Your Case
If you went down on your motorcycle after a deer, and you are not sure whether anyone else's insurance applies, call (717) 724-7503 or request a free case review. You pay no attorney fee unless there is a recovery. You may be responsible for certain case costs and expenses in addition to the fee, as explained in your written fee agreement.
This article is general information about Pennsylvania law, not legal advice for your specific situation, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Attorney advertising. Sean Quinlan, Esq., Quinlan Law Group, Camp Hill, PA.
Serving injured Pennsylvanians in: Philadelphia.
Gladwyne Motorcycle Crash Attorney: Protecting Injured PA Riders
Injured in a Gladwyne motorcycle crash? Learn your rights under PA full tort carve-outs, fault rules, and statutory filing deadlines after a serious wreck.
Motorcycle Accident Attorney in Lancaster: Protecting Your Rights Under PA Law
Injured in a Lancaster motorcycle crash? Learn how PA limited tort exceptions, comparative fault rules, and strict filing deadlines protect your rights after a serious collision.
Philadelphia Motorcycle Accident Attorney
Learn how a Philadelphia motorcycle accident attorney protects your rights, navigates PA motorcycle insurance rules, overcomes limited tort defenses, and secures fair compensation after a crash.
Motorcycle Accident Lawyer Yorktown: Protecting Injured PA Riders
Injured in a motorcycle crash near Yorktown? Learn how Pennsylvania law protects riders, why limited tort does not apply, and how to defend your rights.