Wrongful Death Damages When the Person Was Retired or Not Working in PA

Published November 18, 2026

Written and legally reviewed by Sean P. Quinlan, Esq., PA Attorney ID 86858 — Last updated

Quick answer

Pennsylvania wrongful death and survival claims do not depend on a paycheck. Learn what families can recover when a retiree, homemaker, student or other non-earner is killed by negligence, and what evidence proves it.

When a retiree, homemaker, student or anyone else without a paycheck is killed through another person’s negligence, Pennsylvania law still allows meaningful recovery. A wrongful death action under 42 Pa.C.S. § 8301 benefits the spouse, children or parents and covers medical, funeral and administration expenses plus the value of the services the person provided to the family, which Pennsylvania appellate courts read to include society, comfort and guidance, not just chores. A separate survival action under § 8302 belongs to the estate and can include the person’s conscious pain and suffering and lost earning power, less personal maintenance. Both claims generally must be filed within two years under 42 Pa.C.S. § 5524(2), and the evidence that proves a non-earner’s value to the family has to be gathered deliberately.

Families often hear a version of the same sentence from an insurance adjuster, a neighbor, or their own worried thinking: “Mom was retired, so there’s no lost income, so there isn’t much of a case.” In this article I explain why that assumption is wrong under Pennsylvania law, which parts of a claim do and do not depend on wages, and what evidence matters when the person who died was not earning a salary. This page is a focused companion to the broader overview on our Pennsylvania wrongful death practice page. If you want the general list of damage categories first, start with what damages a Pennsylvania family can recover, then come back here for the non-earner specifics.

Why “No Paycheck” Does Not Mean “No Claim”

Pennsylvania splits a fatal-injury case into two different claims that are usually filed together. The difference between them matters more for a non-earner than for almost anyone else, because the two claims measure loss in completely different ways. (For a side-by-side chart, see wrongful death vs. survival action.)

  • The wrongful death action (42 Pa.C.S. § 8301) compensates certain family members for what they lost. The Pennsylvania Supreme Court in Kiser v. Schulte, 648 A.2d 1 (Pa. 1994), described these damages as including “the present value of the services the deceased would have rendered to the family, had she lived, as well as funeral and medical expenses.” Nothing in that formula requires a paycheck.
  • The survival action (42 Pa.C.S. § 8302) is the claim the person who died could have brought if they had lived, now pursued by the estate. Kiser lists its measure as “the decedent’s pain and suffering, the loss of gross earning power from the date of injury until death, and the loss of his earning power — less personal maintenance expenses, from the time of death through his estimated working life span.”

Put simply: the survival claim is the one that leans on earning power. The wrongful death claim leans on what the person meant to, and did for, the people left behind. For a retiree, homemaker or student, the wrongful death side is frequently the heart of the case, and the survival side may still carry real value through pain and suffering and, in some situations, non-wage income tied to past work.

Who Can Recover When the Person Who Died Was Not Working

Section 8301(b) says the wrongful death right of action exists “for the benefit of the spouse, children or parents of the deceased,” and the statute places no age limit on “children” or “parents.” That has practical consequences for non-earner cases:

  • A retired person may leave a surviving spouse and adult children. Both may be wrongful death beneficiaries. Whether a particular adult child’s loss is large or small depends on the evidence of the relationship and the help that flowed between them, not on the child’s age.
  • A homemaker or stay-at-home parent commonly leaves a spouse and children whose daily lives depended on that person’s work and care.
  • A student or young adult who was not yet earning much may leave parents as the beneficiaries. In Rettger v. UPMC Shadyside, 991 A.2d 915 (Pa. Super. 2010), the Superior Court upheld a wrongful death award to the parents of an adult son and rejected the argument that his “services” to them amounted to little more than yard work. Parents whose minor child died face additional issues covered in what parents can recover for a child’s death.

Procedurally, Pa.R.C.P. 2202 provides that the personal representative brings the action for the benefit of those entitled to recover; if no action is filed within six months of the death, Rule 2202(b) lets the personal representative or a person entitled to recover bring it as trustee ad litem. If no § 8301(b) beneficiary survives, § 8301(d) still allows the personal representative to recover the medical, funeral and administration expenses. Questions about opening an estate are addressed in do we have to open an estate before filing.

Wrongful Death Damages That Do Not Depend on Wages

Medical, funeral and administration expenses

Section 8301(c) says the plaintiff “shall be entitled to recover, in addition to other damages, damages for reasonable hospital, nursing, medical, funeral expenses and expenses of administration” caused by the injuries. These are the same whether the person was a surgeon or a retired seamstress. A deeper look at what qualifies is in funeral, burial and estate expenses after a fatal crash.

The value of services — read broadly

This is where non-earner cases are won or undervalued. Pennsylvania courts have repeatedly said that wrongful death “services” are not limited to housework:

  • Rettger, quoting the Superior Court’s earlier decision in Slaseman v. Myers, stated that “Damages for wrongful death are the value of the decedent’s life to the family, as well as expenses caused to the family by reason of the death,” and that family members may recover “for the value of his services, including society and comfort.” The court added that the term services “clearly extends to the profound emotional and psychological loss suffered upon the death of a parent or a child.”
  • Machado v. Kunkel, 804 A.2d 1238 (Pa. Super. 2002), held that a child can recover “for the loss of companionship, comfort, society and guidance of a parent,” an element also described as “loss of guidance, tutelage, and moral upbringing,” and quoted earlier case law listing contributions “for such items as shelter, food, clothing, medical care, education, entertainment, gifts and recreation.”
  • In McMichael v. McMichael, 241 A.3d 582 (Pa. 2020), the Pennsylvania Supreme Court repeated its long-standing description of these losses: “companionship, comfort, society, guidance, solace, and protection which go into the vase of family happiness [ ] are the things for which a wrongdoer must pay when he shatters the vase.”

For a non-earner, “services” can therefore include both the practical and the personal. The table below translates that into the kinds of contributions families describe most often.

Who diedPractical services often at issueRelationship losses often at issue
Retired parent or grandparentRegular childcare for grandchildren, rides to appointments, home repairs, help managing a spouse’s medications, financial gifts or help to adult childrenCompanionship to a spouse of many decades; guidance and comfort to adult children
Homemaker or stay-at-home parentCooking, cleaning, laundry, transportation, household management, care of children or an elderly relativeGuidance, tutelage and moral upbringing of children; companionship and comfort to a spouse
Student or young adultHelp around the parents’ home, care for younger siblings, help to aging parentsSociety and comfort to parents (the loss the Rettger court called “profound emotional and psychological”)
Disabled or unemployed adultWhatever help the person actually gave the household, even if limitedCompanionship, comfort and society to spouse, children or parents

The listed items are examples of the kinds of evidence that may be offered, not a promise that any particular item will be valued in any particular way. How these categories apply to a specific family is a question an attorney can confirm after reviewing the facts.

Survival Damages for a Non-Earner

Conscious pain and suffering

Under the measure stated in Kiser, the estate’s survival claim includes “the decedent’s pain and suffering.” This element does not depend on employment at all. When a person survived for a period after the injury — at the scene, in transport, or in a hospital — evidence of what they went through can matter a great deal, and it is often the largest survival component when there were no wages. The separate guide to the Pennsylvania survival action explains how this claim is handled generally.

Earning power when there was no salary

The survival measure speaks of “earning power,” not just wages actually being paid on the date of death. A few verified points from Pennsylvania appellate decisions shape how that works for non-earners:

  • Students and young people. In Kiser itself, the young woman who died was enrolled in a two-year college program, and the economic evidence at trial projected earnings over a working lifetime for a high school graduate and a college graduate, minus personal maintenance. The Supreme Court affirmed a new trial on damages because the jury’s award bore no reasonable relation to that uncontroverted evidence. A person does not have to be on a payroll for future earning power to be at issue.
  • Retirees with Social Security or pension income. In Thompson v. Philadelphia, 294 A.2d 826 (Pa. Super. 1972), the decedent was about 82 years old, and the Superior Court found “no error” in allowing the jury “to consider the $110 monthly social security payments when determining decedent’s loss of earning capacity,” quoting a federal decision that allowed retirement pension and Social Security income as “some measure” of earning capacity. In Murdoch v. Commonwealth, 531 A.2d 1164 (Pa. Cmwlth. 1987), the Commonwealth Court explained that “Social Security and Veterans benefits are a product of the intellectual and physical labor of the claimant.”
  • Investment and trust income is different. Murdoch held that a decedent’s testamentary trust income was not recoverable in a survival action because it was not the product of her labor, and that “capital investment income is not compensable in a survival action” because it is “not lost upon death.”
  • Personal maintenance is deducted. Whatever earning power is proved, Kiser subtracts “personal maintenance expenses” — what the person would have spent on themselves. For a retiree on a fixed income, that deduction can consume much of the figure, which is one more reason the wrongful death side usually carries more weight.

These cases do not create a fixed formula for retirees or homemakers, and courts evaluate the evidence case by case. An attorney can confirm how earning-capacity evidence would apply to a particular person’s situation.

How the two claims fit together

Section 8301(a) requires that prior actions for the same injuries be consolidated with the wrongful death claim “so as to avoid a duplicate recovery,” and Kiser explains that the two actions are cumulative but may not overlap. In practice, a non-earner’s practical help to the family is typically presented as wrongful death “services,” while the estate’s claim focuses on pain and suffering and any provable earning power.

Mistakes Families Make in Non-Earner Death Cases

  1. Assuming there is no economic loss. A retiree who watched grandchildren four days a week, or a homemaker who ran the household, provided services that cost money to replace.
  2. Proving the services but not their value. This is the lesson of McMichael. The surviving wife testified that her husband did home repairs, mowed the lawn, did most of the cooking and drove her to work in bad weather, but the Supreme Court noted that neither she nor her expert “testified to the estimated value of these contributions, or the cost of hiring someone to perform these tasks.” The Court upheld a zero award for economic damages on that record, while ordering a new trial on non-economic damages. The majority did not hold that an expert is always required, but the jury needed some basis to value the services rather than guess.
  3. Letting the relationship evidence go undocumented. The companionship and guidance losses described in Rettger, Machado and McMichael are proved through people: family members, friends, neighbors, clergy, coworkers from volunteer work. Memories fade, and witnesses move.
  4. Signing a release that covers the estate’s claim without court approval. As explained below, the estate’s survival claim cannot be validly settled without a court’s approval, and a minor beneficiary’s interest needs approval too.
  5. Waiting because “there is time.” The survival claim’s clock can start before death, as the deadline section explains.
  6. Giving a recorded statement to the at-fault party’s insurer that minimizes what the person did for the family (“she was retired and just stayed home”). Describe nothing about value until you understand how Pennsylvania measures it.

Evidence That Shows a Non-Earner’s Value

Because McMichael requires evidence from which a jury can value services, families can start building the record now:

  • A week-by-week picture of what the person did. Calendars, text messages arranging pickups, pharmacy and appointment records showing who drove, school pickup lists, church or volunteer schedules.
  • What it now costs to replace those services. Invoices or quotes for childcare, home health aides, cleaning, lawn care, transportation or meal services that the family has had to buy since the death.
  • Financial help that flowed to family members. Records of gifts, tuition help, or regular support to adult children or grandchildren (the Machado line of cases recognizes contributions for items such as education, gifts and recreation).
  • Income records for the survival claim. Social Security benefit statements, pension statements, records of part-time or seasonal work, and for students, transcripts, enrollment records and any job offers or internships.
  • Health records. Life expectancy and health before the injury affect how long services and earning power would likely have continued; expect the defense to examine them.
  • Witnesses. A short written list of people who saw the relationship firsthand, with contact information.

For more general questions about evidence and value, the compensation FAQ and the plain-English overview of what families can recover in a wrongful death claim are helpful starting points.

Why Act Now: The Pennsylvania Deadlines

42 Pa.C.S. § 5524(2) requires that “An action to recover damages for injuries to the person or for the death of an individual” caused by another’s negligence “must be commenced within two years.” The two claims do not always start on the same day:

  • Wrongful death: In Moyer v. Rubright, 651 A.2d 1139 (Pa. Super. 1994), relying on Pastierik v. Duquesne Light Co., 526 A.2d 323 (Pa. 1987), the court explained there is “no basis to regard the cause of action for death as accruing at any time other than at death.”
  • Survival: Moyer held that the survival clock starts when the injured person knew or should have known of the claim, and “the statute runs, at the latest, from death.” In Moyer, the survival claim was time-barred even though the wrongful death claim was not.

That gap matters in non-earner cases involving older adults, where an injury (a fall, a crash, a medical error) may come months before the death. Claims against government entities can carry additional requirements, such as the six-month notice provision in 42 Pa.C.S. § 5522. The statute of limitations FAQ covers those issues, and an attorney can confirm the exact dates that apply to your family.

Court Approval and Who Receives the Money

Settlement rules differ between the two claims:

  • Survival claim: In Schuster v. Reeves, 589 A.2d 731 (Pa. Super. 1991), the Superior Court held that “Before a survival claim can be settled on behalf of a decedent’s estate, however, such a settlement must be judicially approved,” under 20 Pa.C.S. § 3323.
  • Wrongful death claim: Schuster held that where the only beneficiaries are competent adults, “they may settle their claims without court approval.” But under Pa.R.C.P. 2206(a), when a minor or incapacitated person has an interest, the settlement requires court approval “as being fair and equitable.” That situation comes up when a homemaker or young parent leaves minor children.
  • Distribution: Wrongful death damages are distributed to the beneficiaries “in the proportion they would take the personal estate of the decedent in the case of intestacy” and “without liability to creditors of the deceased person,” per § 8301(b). Survival proceeds belong to the estate. Because a retiree’s estate may have debts, the split between the two claims can matter to the family; see who gets wrongful death settlement money and court approval for wrongful death settlements.

What Happens Next

  1. Preserve the evidence and records described above, including the crash or incident report, medical records, and documents showing what the person did for the family.
  2. Open the estate (or confirm who the personal representative will be), since the survival claim belongs to the estate and Rule 2202 assigns the personal representative the first opportunity to file the wrongful death action.
  3. Identify every beneficiary under § 8301(b): spouse, children (including adult children) and parents.
  4. Investigate liability and insurance coverage, including any parties beyond the obvious one.
  5. Develop damages evidence: replacement-cost evidence for services, relationship witnesses, and, where relevant, Social Security, pension or education records.
  6. File within the deadlines if the claim does not resolve, keeping in mind that the survival deadline may run from an earlier date than the wrongful death deadline.
  7. Obtain court approval for any settlement of the survival claim and for any minor’s or incapacitated beneficiary’s share, and allocate the recovery between the two claims.

Why Talk With Sean Quinlan

Sean Quinlan has been a Pennsylvania attorney since 2001, with offices in Camp Hill and Harrisburg. A free, confidential consultation can cover who the beneficiaries are, how the wrongful death and survival claims apply when the person who died was retired, a homemaker or a student, which deadlines may apply, and what records are worth gathering now. There is no obligation to go forward. More background is on the wrongful death FAQ.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is there any earnings-based claim if my father was retired?

Possibly, in a limited way. The survival action measures “earning power,” and in Thompson v. Philadelphia the Superior Court allowed a jury to consider an elderly decedent’s Social Security payments as some measure of earning capacity, not as proof of lost income. Investment and trust income generally is not recoverable, per Murdoch v. Commonwealth, and personal maintenance is deducted. For most retirees, the larger component is the wrongful death claim for the value of their services, society and comfort to the family.

My wife was a stay-at-home mother. What can our family recover?

Under 42 Pa.C.S. § 8301, the family can seek medical, funeral and administration expenses plus the value of the services she provided, which Pennsylvania courts read to include household work as well as guidance, tutelage and moral upbringing of children. The estate may also pursue a survival claim for any conscious pain and suffering. Evidence of what it costs to replace her household work is important under McMichael v. McMichael.

Can adult children recover when a retired parent dies?

Section 8301(b) names the “children” of the deceased as beneficiaries without an age limit, so adult children may share in the wrongful death recovery. What their loss is worth depends on the evidence of the relationship and the help that passed between them, such as caregiving, guidance or financial gifts.

Do we need an economist to prove the value of household services?

Not always. In McMichael, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court did not require expert testimony in every case, but it upheld a zero economic award where no evidence was offered about the value of the services or the cost of hiring someone to perform them. Some evidence of value, from an expert or from replacement-cost records, is needed.

How long do we have to file?

Generally two years under 42 Pa.C.S. § 5524(2). The wrongful death claim runs from the date of death, provided the injured person’s own claim was still timely when they died (Moyer v. Rubright), but the survival claim can begin running earlier, when the injured person knew or should have known of the claim. Claims involving government entities may have additional notice requirements.

Talk to a Pennsylvania Injury Lawyer About Your Case

If someone you love was retired, ran your household, was still in school, or was otherwise not drawing a paycheck when another person’s negligence took their life, the law still recognizes what your family lost. Call (717) 724-7503 or request a free case review to talk through the wrongful death and survival claims, the deadlines and the evidence that matters. You pay no attorney fee unless there is a recovery. You may be responsible for certain case costs and expenses in addition to the fee, as explained in your written fee agreement.

This article is general information about Pennsylvania law, not legal advice for your specific situation, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Attorney advertising. Sean Quinlan, Esq., Quinlan Law Group, Camp Hill, PA.

Sources

More on this topic

Injured in Pennsylvania? Call Sean Quinlan at (717) 724-7503 for a free case review.