Child Brain Injury After a PA Crash: Deadlines, Parent Claims, and Court Approval
Written and legally reviewed by Sean P. Quinlan, Esq., PA Attorney ID 86858 — Last updated
How Pennsylvania handles a child traumatic brain injury claim after a crash: the tolled deadline for the child, the separate two-year parent claim, limited tort, and Rule 2039 court approval.
When a child suffers a traumatic brain injury in a Pennsylvania crash, two separate claims usually exist. The child's own claim for pain and suffering and adult losses is tolled until age 18 under 42 Pa.C.S. § 5533(b), then the normal two-year limit in § 5524(2) applies. The parents' claim for medical expenses during minority is a separate cause of action that is not tolled; the Superior Court held in Hathi v. Krewstown Park Apartments (1989) that it runs two years from the injury. Any settlement of the child's claim requires court approval under Pa.R.C.P. 2039, which also restricts how the money is held until the child turns 18.
In this article I explain how those rules fit together after a car, truck, bus, bicycle or pedestrian crash, how limited tort can reach a child through the household auto policy, and what a court reviews before approving a settlement. For the basics of minors' deadlines, see my overview of the Pennsylvania statute of limitations for minors.
Why a Child's Brain Injury Claim Is Different
A brain injury in a child does not always announce itself in the emergency department. The U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) warns parents that "concussion signs and symptoms may not show up right away—they may take hours or days to appear or be noticed." The CDC also notes that "Spotting a possible concussion may be harder in young children and some children with disabilities because they may not be able to communicate or express how they feel."
For school-aged children and teens, the CDC lists signs such as appearing dazed or confused, sudden difficulty remembering or concentrating, answering questions more slowly than usual, slowed reaction times, and mood, behavior or personality changes.
Recovery also varies. In its guidance on what to do after a concussion, the CDC says most children feel better within 2 to 4 weeks, but that "Some children have symptoms that effect their behavior, mood, memory, or emotions for months or longer." A family may not know for months or years how a brain injury will affect a child's learning and future work. The law gives the child time, but not the parents.
For a broader look at how brain injuries are documented and proven after a collision, see my article on car accident brain injury symptoms and proof. The Pennsylvania brain injury practice page collects related resources.
Two Claims, Two Clocks: The Child's Claim and the Parents' Claim
Pennsylvania treats an injury to a minor as giving rise to two different claims that belong to different people. The Superior Court adopted that framework in Hathi v. Krewstown Park Apartments, 385 Pa. Super. 613, 561 A.2d 1261 (1989), quoting a federal decision: "Under Pennsylvania law personal injury to a minor gives rise to two separate and distinct causes of action, one the parents claim for medical expenses and loss of the minor's services during minority, the other the minor's claim for pain and suffering and for losses after minority."
| Claim | Who owns it | Typical damages | Deadline |
|---|---|---|---|
| The child's claim | The child (brought by a guardian while the child is a minor) | Pain and suffering, loss of enjoyment of life, disfigurement, losses after age 18 such as lost earning capacity and adult medical care | Tolled during minority under 42 Pa.C.S. § 5533(b); two years after the 18th birthday under § 5524(2) |
| The parents' claim | The parent or parents | Medical expenses during minority and loss of the child's services during minority | Two years from the injury under § 5524(2); not extended by the child's minority (Hathi) |
The child's deadline: tolled until 18
Under 42 Pa.C.S. § 5533(b)(1)(i), if a person entitled to sue is an unemancipated minor when the claim accrues, "the period of minority shall not be deemed a portion of the time period within which the action must be commenced." The statute defines a minor as an individual who has not yet reached 18. The child then has "the same time for commencing an action after attaining majority as is allowed to others," which for a negligence claim is the two-year period in 42 Pa.C.S. § 5524(2). In plain terms, the child's own crash claim generally must be filed by the child's 20th birthday.
The parents' deadline: two years from the crash
In Hathi, the parents sued more than two years after their son was hurt and argued that their own claim should ride along with his tolled claim. The Superior Court rejected that argument. It held that the parents' claim was not derivative of the child's, that the parents had not been minors themselves, and that they "do not receive the benefit of § 5533(b)." The court concluded: "Accordingly, the trial court properly determined that their claim was barred by the two-year statute of limitations."
Many families hear that a child "has until 20" and assume the whole case can wait. It cannot. If the parents paid or owe hospital bills, neurology visits, therapy, and medication costs during the child's minority, the claim for those expenses generally belongs to the parents and generally must be filed within two years of the crash. In a motor vehicle case, 75 Pa.C.S. § 1722 generally bars recovering in the tort claim medical expenses that were paid or payable by first-party auto benefits and certain other benefit programs, so the parents' claim often centers on costs those sources did not cover. The statute of limitations FAQ covers the general two-year rule and its main exceptions.
Both claims are usually brought together
Pennsylvania's procedural rules also push the two claims into one lawsuit. Pa.R.C.P. 2228(b) provides that when an injury not resulting in death is inflicted on a minor and causes of action accrue to the minor and the parents, "they shall be enforced in one action brought by the parent or parents and the child." The rule adds that if the parents live apart, the action is brought by the parent who has custody of the child and control of the child's services. And under Pa.R.C.P. 2027, a minor who is a party "shall be represented by a guardian who shall supervise and control the conduct of the action in behalf of the minor." Exactly how these joinder rules interact with the two different deadlines in a given case is something an attorney can confirm for your family.
What Compensation May Be Available After a Child's Brain Injury
Because two claims exist, the categories of loss divide between the child and the parents. Every case turns on its own facts and proof, and no particular result can be predicted, but the categories that may be available include:
- Parents' medical expenses during minority: emergency care, hospitalization, imaging, neurology and neuropsychology visits, therapy, and medications paid or owed during childhood.
- Loss of the child's services during minority: a traditional category that belongs to the parents under the Hathi framework.
- The child's pain and suffering: physical pain, headaches, emotional distress, and the loss of ordinary childhood activities. For a child bound by limited tort, this category depends on meeting the serious injury threshold or an exception, discussed below.
- Losses after age 18: future medical and rehabilitative care as an adult and lost earning capacity if the injury affects the child's ability to work.
- Disfigurement where scarring or other visible injury is involved.
The compensation FAQ explains these damage categories in more detail.
Future medical expenses need medical proof
For a child with a lasting brain injury, future care can be the largest economic item, and Pennsylvania requires it to be proven properly. In Mendralla v. Weaver Corp., 703 A.2d 480 (Pa. Super. 1997) (en banc), the Superior Court held that a party claiming future medical expenses "must prove, by expert testimony, not only that future medical expenses will be incurred, but also the reasonable estimated cost of such services." The court explained that because those costs are not within a layperson's general knowledge, that testimony "eliminates the prospect that the jury’s award will be speculative."
For a child, that usually means treating physicians, repeated neuropsychological testing, and sometimes a life care plan; see how future medical expenses are proven in Pennsylvania and my article on life care plans for catastrophic injury.
First-Party Medical Benefits Come First
In a motor vehicle crash, Pennsylvania's first-party benefits system usually pays the first medical bills. Under 75 Pa.C.S. § 1713(a), the order of priority is: for a named insured, the policy on which he or she is the named insured; for an insured, "the policy covering the insured"; for occupants of an insured vehicle, the policy on that vehicle; and for a person who is not an occupant of a vehicle, such as a child pedestrian or bicyclist, the policy on any vehicle involved in the accident.
For most children, the family's own auto policy is the starting point, because a child who lives in the household is usually an "insured" under it. The medical benefit described in 75 Pa.C.S. § 1712(1) covers reasonable and necessary treatment, including psychological services, speech pathology, and occupational therapy, "all without limitation as to time, provided that, within 18 months from the date of the accident causing injury, it is ascertainable with reasonable medical probability that further expenses may be incurred as a result of the injury." The amount of coverage depends on the policy that was purchased. With a slowly emerging brain injury, getting a child evaluated and documented within that 18-month window can matter.
How first-party benefits, health insurance, and the liability claim are coordinated has its own rules. See my articles on who pays car accident medical bills and on paying back health insurance after a settlement.
Limited Tort Can Reach a Child Through the Household Policy
Many parents are surprised to learn that the tort option they chose on their own auto policy can affect their child's claim. 75 Pa.C.S. § 1705(b)(2) provides that the tort option elected by a named insured "shall apply to all insureds under the private passenger motor vehicle policy who are not named insureds under another private passenger motor vehicle policy." Section 1705(f) defines "insured" to include a resident of the household who is a relative of the named insured or "a minor in the custody of either the named insured or relative of the named insured." So if the household policy carries limited tort, a child living in that household will often be treated as bound by it.
Limited tort does not bar the claim for economic loss, such as medical expenses. Under § 1705(d), it limits recovery of noneconomic loss (pain and suffering) unless the injury is a "serious injury" or an exception applies. Section 1702 defines serious injury as "A personal injury resulting in death, serious impairment of body function or permanent serious disfigurement."
Exceptions worth checking
- No household auto policy: § 1705(b)(3) provides that a person who does not own a registered private passenger vehicle and is not a named insured or insured under any such policy is not precluded from recovering noneconomic loss.
- The at-fault driver's conduct or registration: under § 1705(d)(1), a limited tort insured may recover as if full tort applied when the at-fault driver is convicted of, or accepts ARD for, DUI in that accident, is operating a vehicle registered in another state, intended to injure, or had no financial responsibility.
- The vehicle the child was in: under § 1705(d)(3), a person bound by limited tort retains full tort rights if injured while an occupant of a vehicle other than a "private passenger motor vehicle," a term § 1702 defines by vehicle type and use. Whether a particular bus, van, or commercial vehicle qualifies is fact-specific, and an attorney can confirm how this applies to your case.
Is a child's brain injury a "serious injury"?
The Pennsylvania Supreme Court addressed the test in Washington v. Baxter, 719 A.2d 733 (Pa. 1998). The Court quoted and applied a two-question test drawn from a Michigan decision, DiFranco: what body function, if any, was impaired because of the injuries, and was that impairment serious? That quoted test lists factors including "the extent of the impairment, the length of time the impairment lasted, the treatment required to correct the impairment, and any other relevant factors," and adds that "An impairment need not be permanent to be serious." The Court also held that the threshold question is generally for the jury "unless reasonable minds could not differ on the issue of whether a serious injury had been sustained."
For a child, the relevant body functions can include memory, attention, processing speed, balance, sleep, and emotional regulation, and the evidence often comes from teachers and school records as well as doctors. I go deeper on this in whether a concussion is a serious injury under limited tort, and the limited tort vs. full tort comparison lays out the two options side by side.
Court Approval of a Minor's Settlement Under Rule 2039
A parent cannot simply sign a release for a child's injury claim. Pa.R.C.P. 2039(a) states: "No action to which a minor is a party shall be compromised, settled or discontinued except after approval by the court pursuant to a petition presented by the guardian of the minor."
What the court reviews
Under Rule 2039(b), once a settlement is approved, the court also approves or disapproves the agreement for "the payment of counsel fees and other expenses out of the fund," or fixes those fees and expenses itself. Many county courts of common pleas also have local rules on what a minor's compromise petition must contain, so the paperwork can differ from county to county.
Where the child's money goes
The balance of the fund is paid to a guardian of the minor's estate if one exists or is to be appointed. If not, Rule 2039(b) lets the court order one or more of the following:
- Up to $25,000 paid for the benefit of the minor to the guardian of the person, the natural guardian, the person or agency maintaining the minor, or the minor.
- Deposit in federally insured savings accounts, or accounts investing only in government-guaranteed securities, in the child's name. Every such order must provide that "no withdrawal can be made from any such account until the minor attains majority, except as authorized by a prior order of the court."
- A structured settlement underwritten by a financially responsible entity, with any payments made during minority going into a restricted account.
- A trust with an independent corporate fiduciary that remains subject to the court's continuing jurisdiction.
For a child with a lasting brain injury, the choice among these options can affect benefits eligibility and long-term care planning. Two related articles may help: structured settlements vs. lump sums and special needs trusts and Medicaid or SSI eligibility.
Timing: settle now or wait?
There can be reasons to wait before resolving the child's claim, such as letting a brain injury's long-term effects become clearer through follow-up testing, and reasons not to, such as lost evidence or insurance limits. The parents' claim keeps its own two-year clock. My settle vs. file a lawsuit comparison explains the general trade-offs.
Mistakes Parents Should Avoid
- Assuming the whole case can wait until the child turns 18. The parents' claim for medical expenses during minority generally runs two years from the injury.
- Missing a government notice deadline. If a city, township, school district, or state agency may be responsible, 42 Pa.C.S. § 5522(a) requires written notice within six months in many cases. Do not assume the child's extended deadline covers this notice requirement; an attorney can confirm how it applies to your case.
- Skipping follow-up care because the child "seems fine." The CDC notes symptoms may take hours or days to appear or be noticed, and the first-party medical benefit depends on further expenses being ascertainable within 18 months.
- Not keeping school records. Report cards, teacher notes, attendance, and any classroom supports before and after the crash can show how the injury affected learning. The CDC offers a HEADS UP letter to schools that a child's health care provider can fill out.
- Signing a release or accepting a check for the child's claim. Once a lawsuit is filed, a minor's claim cannot be settled without court approval under Rule 2039, and settlements reached before suit raise their own approval issues that an attorney can explain.
- Giving a recorded statement to the other driver's insurer before understanding how the limited tort and serious injury issues may apply.
Why Act Now
The child's claim may be tolled, but the parents' two-year deadline and any six-month government notice deadline are not. Crash evidence, vehicle data, and witness memories fade, and for a child with subtle symptoms, early medical and school records often best show the change from before the crash to after it. If police responded, the crash report is a useful early document; the Pennsylvania State Police explain how to request a copy of a vehicle crash report.
What Happens Next
- Medical care. The child's treatment comes first, including pediatric follow-up and any neurology or neuropsychology referrals.
- Insurance review. The household auto policy is identified, including the tort option and first-party coverage, along with the at-fault driver's coverage.
- Evidence preservation. A preservation letter can be sent to the at-fault driver and any commercial owner, and the crash report, photos, and witness information are gathered.
- Deadline mapping. The parents' two-year deadline, the child's tolled deadline, and any government notice deadline are calculated.
- Damages development. Medical, school, and testing records are collected over time, and future care needs are evaluated with qualified medical testimony when appropriate.
- Negotiation or suit. The claims may be resolved through negotiation or a lawsuit filed in the county court of common pleas.
- Court approval. Any settlement of the child's claim is presented by petition for approval under Rule 2039, and the court directs how the child's funds are held.
Why Talk to This Firm
I have been a Pennsylvania attorney since 2001, with offices in Camp Hill and Harrisburg. A consultation is free and confidential. In it, you can go over the crash, the child's symptoms and treatment so far, the household auto policy and tort option, which deadlines apply to the child's claim and to your own claim as a parent, and how court approval of a minor's settlement works.
Frequently Asked Questions
How long does my child have to file a brain injury claim in Pennsylvania?
Under 42 Pa.C.S. § 5533(b), the time a child is under 18 does not count toward the limitations period. The child then has the normal two years under § 5524(2), so the child's own negligence claim generally must be filed by the 20th birthday. Government notice rules and other exceptions can shorten practical timelines.
Do parents have a separate deadline for their child's medical bills?
Yes. In Hathi v. Krewstown Park Apartments (Pa. Super. 1989), the court held that the parents' claim for medical expenses and loss of services during minority is separate from the child's claim and is not extended by the child's minority. It generally must be filed within two years of the injury.
Does a court have to approve a settlement for my child?
Yes. Pa.R.C.P. 2039(a) provides that no action to which a minor is a party may be compromised, settled, or discontinued without court approval on a petition by the minor's guardian. The court also approves counsel fees and expenses paid from the fund and directs how the child's money is held.
Can I use my child's settlement money before they turn 18?
Generally not freely. Rule 2039 allows the court to order deposits in restricted accounts from which no withdrawal can be made until the minor reaches majority except by prior court order, or to approve a structured settlement or a court-supervised trust. A limited amount, up to $25,000, may be ordered paid for the minor's benefit to a guardian or the person maintaining the minor.
Does my limited tort election apply to my child?
Often it does. Under 75 Pa.C.S. § 1705(b)(2) and (f), the tort option on a household policy generally applies to insureds, which includes a minor in the custody of the named insured or a relative who lives in the household. Exceptions in § 1705 may apply, and a brain injury may qualify as a serious injury under the Washington v. Baxter test.
What if my child's brain injury symptoms show up weeks after the crash?
The CDC states that concussion signs and symptoms may take hours or days to appear or be noticed, and that spotting them can be harder in young children. Get the child evaluated, tell the provider about the crash, and keep records of changes at home and school.
Talk to a Pennsylvania Injury Lawyer About Your Case
If your child suffered a head or brain injury in a Pennsylvania crash, call (717) 724-7503 or request a free case review. The free review covers how the crash happened, your child's symptoms and treatment, the household auto policy and tort option, the separate deadlines for your child's claim and your own claim as a parent, and how court approval of a minor's settlement works. You pay no attorney fee unless there is a recovery. You may be responsible for certain case costs and expenses in addition to the fee, as explained in your written fee agreement.
This article is general information about Pennsylvania law, not legal advice for your specific situation, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Attorney advertising. Sean Quinlan, Esq., Quinlan Law Group, Camp Hill, PA.
Serving injured Pennsylvanians in: Philadelphia.
Sources
- "concussion signs and symptoms may not show up right away—they may take hours or days to appear or be noticed."
- what to do after a concussion
- Hathi v. Krewstown Park Apartments, 385 Pa. Super. 613, 561 A.2d 1261 (1989)
- 42 Pa.C.S. § 5533(b)(1)(i)
- 42 Pa.C.S. § 5524(2)
- Pa.R.C.P. 2228(b)
- Pa.R.C.P. 2027
- 75 Pa.C.S. § 1713(a)
- 75 Pa.C.S. § 1712(1)
- 75 Pa.C.S. § 1705(b)(2)
- Washington v. Baxter, 719 A.2d 733 (Pa. 1998)
- Pa.R.C.P. 2039(a)
- request a copy of a vehicle crash report